Right
about now, after months of reports, media hype, and the seeming inexorable march
of “bird flu” across the world, the best advice I can offer about avian flu
is “Everybody breathe regular.” Avian flu is a topic of great concern and
potentially devastating import. It is a matter that we should all take time to
educate ourselves about and keep half an eye on. It is not the sort of thing the
average person should make vacation plans, let alone life decisions about, at
least not yet.
There
is understandable and continuous concern among global health authorities about
the rapid and deadly spread of “avian influenza” (AI) throughout the
world’s bird populations. AI is nothing new. This particular strain, H5N1, has
been around for years, and since 1997 there have been a small but steady number
of laboratory confirmed human infections with AI.
Nearly
all of these cases occurred in people who had direct contact with birds and to
date that has been the only way that every human has been infected with AI; from
close and familiar contact with birds. What is sometimes lost is that while
there have been an increasing number of infected people, they still represent
only a tiny fraction of those that can actually be classified as “at risk.”
The
purpose of this article is to place the whole avian flu situation into context
and offer some perspective. We’ll focus our attention on basic information
about AI in bird populations. We’ll also be looking at how humans are affected
by avian flu and review the potential for a pandemic of human to human avian
flu.
Avian
Influenza: An Epizootic
Avian
Influenza (AI), sometimes called “Bird Flu” or “Avian Flu,” is a highly
contagious viral infection that can infect birds of all species. Scientists
first identified the disease over a century ago and it occurs worldwide.
Migrating wild birds are known to carry AI in their intestines, usually without
becoming ill due to natural resistance.
Over
the last few years, AI has been spreading around the world as part of an
apparent epizootic (an epizootic is a global outbreak of a disease in animals; a
pandemic is a global outbreak of a disease in humans). It appears that migrating
birds are spreading the disease to domestic poultry populations. Virtually every
human case has resulted from contact with domestic chickens, ducks, or geese.
The
Virus
AI
is caused by the “A” type influenza virus which belongs to the
Orthomyxovirus family. Several subtypes of influenza A exist. And although it is
possible for other species (including humans) to acquire AI infection, it occurs
primarily in birds. Influenza infections in birds are divided in two groups
based on pathogenicity (ability to cause disease).
The
first and most common type of AI is known as Low Pathogenic Avian Influenza
(LPAI). It generally causes a mild form of the disease, with mild or no
symptoms. Secondary infections or environmental conditions may exacerbate LPAI
infections, leading to more serious disease. The symptoms of LPAI in poultry
consist primarily of mild respiratory disease, depression, and decreased egg
production in laying birds. Current research indicates that some LPAI virus
subtypes can mutate into the much more dangerous and virulent Highly Pathogenic
Avian Influenza (HPAI).
Clinical
signs of HPAI are depression, loss of appetite, cessation of egg laying, nervous
signs, swelling and blue discoloration of the wattles (due to disturbance of
blood circulation), coughing, sneezing, and diarrhea. Sudden death may occur
without any prior symptoms. The incubation periods of both HPAI and LPAI range
from a few hours up to three days in individual birds.
HPAI
strains can be devastating infections in poultry, sometimes with local mortality
rates as high as 100%. Since 1959, when recording first started, there has been
a steady increase in reports of HPAI outbreaks in domestic bird populations,
though whether this is due to an actual increase in the disease or simply better
reporting is unclear.
The
H5N1 AI virus subtype is of particular concern. The incidence of H5N1 has been
increasing significantly since the first reports of outbreaks on poultry farms
in Hong Kong in 1997. As of 2005, both domestic and wild birds are dying in
record numbers due to HPAI resulting from infection with H5N1.
AI
Transmission Among Birds
All
the current evidence suggests that AI viruses are normally spread by wild
waterfowl, although gulls and shorebirds have also been implicated. Direct
contact between wild birds and poultry does not appear to be necessary for the
introduction of the virus into poultry farms. AI is often spread through wild
bird excrement that contains the virus. Drinking water may also become a source
of infection if contaminated with AI. On farms, AI is transmitted through direct
contact of infected poultry with healthy poultry through highly contagious
respiratory secretions, saliva, and feces.
AI
is also indirectly spread on an individual farm through contact with
contaminated farm equipment or even workers. The spread of AI virus from one
farm to another usually occurs when infectious excrement is mechanically
transferred by farm workers or drivers visiting the farm, moving birds, or
delivering food. So ironically, humans are spreading the outbreak to birds and
may therefore be setting the stage for the disease to jump to humans.
Avian
Flu and Humans
According
to the World Health Organization (WHO), “Avian influenza viruses do not
normally infect species other than birds and pigs.” However, there have been a
number of confirmed human cases of H5N1 Avian Influenza since the first case was
documented in 1997. To date, all these cases have been attributed to direct
contact with infected poultry and/or exposure to contaminated surfaces.
The
current outbreak began in the middle of 2003 and has seen a steady trickle of
laboratory-confirmed human cases of H5N1 Avian Influenza. To date, nine Asian
countries have reported outbreaks (listed in order of reporting): the Republic
of Korea, Viet Nam, Japan, Thailand, Cambodia, the Lao People’s Democratic
Republic, Indonesia, China, and Malaysia. Of these, Japan, the Republic of
Korea, and Malaysia have controlled their outbreaks and are now considered free
of the disease. Elsewhere in Asia, the virus has become endemic in several of
the initially affected countries.
In
late July 2005, the virus spread to affect poultry and wild birds in the Russian
Federation and adjacent parts of Kazakhstan. Almost simultaneously, Mongolia
reported detection of the highly pathogenic virus in wild birds. In October
2005, the virus was reported in Turkey, Romania, and Croatia. In early December
2005, Ukraine reported its first outbreak in domestic birds. Further spread of
the virus along the migratory routes of wild waterfowl is, however, anticipated.
Since
bird migration is an annual recurring event, countries on the flyways from
central Asia will likely face continuous risk of introduction or re-introduction
of the virus to domestic poultry flocks.
Transmission
to People
In
humans, influenza viruses are transmitted through the inhalation of infectious
respiratory secretions. Another way is through direct contact or indirect
contact with contaminated environmental surfaces and subsequent self-inoculation
through the respiratory tract or the conjunctiva (the mucous membrane
surrounding the eye). Evidence has shown that H5N1 infections in humans have
occurred through bird-to-human transmission and possibly through
environment-to-human infection. Household clusters have been reported, which
raises the question of human-to-human transmission.
Still,
H5N1 avian influenza remains largely a disease of birds. Despite the infection
of tens of millions of poultry over large geographical areas since mid-2003,
fewer than 170 human cases have been laboratory confirmed. All cases have been
reported in six countries, all but one of which are in Asia: Cambodia, China,
Indonesia, Thailand, Turkey, and Viet Nam. The first patients in the current
outbreak, which were reported from Viet Nam, developed symptoms in December
2003. Thailand reported its first cases on 23 January 2004. The first case in
Cambodia was reported on 2 February 2005. The next country to report cases was
Indonesia, which confirmed its first infection on 21 July. China’s first two
cases were reported on 16 November 2005. Confirmation of the first cases in
Turkey came on 5 January 2006, followed by the first reported case in Iraq on 30
January 2006. All human cases have coincided with outbreaks of highly pathogenic
H5N1 avian influenza in poultry. To date, Viet Nam has been the most severely
affected country, with more than 90 cases.
For
unknown reasons, most cases have occurred in rural households or on farms on the
outskirts of cities where small flocks of poultry are kept. Very few cases have
been detected in presumed high-risk groups, such as commercial poultry workers,
workers at live poultry markets, cullers, veterinarians, and health staff caring
for patients without adequate protective equipment. Another puzzle is the
concentration of cases in previously healthy children and young adults, and what
if anything these mean.
In
January 2005, the World Health Organization (WHO) described the first,
“probable secondary human transmission resulting in severe disease” because
the case occurred between close family contacts (a mother and her young child in
Thailand in September 2004). The exact nature of the transmission is yet to be
proven and no similar cases have been identified.
Symptoms
in Humans
Symptoms
of AI H5N1 are fever (less than 38°C), lower respiratory tract symptoms (i.e.
cough, difficulty in breathing, chest pain, wheeze) accompanied by an
influenza-like illness. There may be upper respiratory tract symptoms (i.e.
sneezing, nasal congestion). Unlike some other types of influenza,
conjunctivitis is not common in cases of H5N1. There have been reports of
gastrointestinal tract distress, pleuritic pain (the pleura is the membrane
covering the lungs), and bleeding from the nose and gums in some cases. The
incubation of H5N1 in humans is usually between two to four days, but can take
up to eight days (which is longer than other types of human influenza).
Is
This the Start of an H5N1 Influenza Pandemic?
During
the 20th century, there were three severe influenza pandemics: the “Spanish
Flu” of 1918, another in 1957 (the “Asian Flu), and the so-called “Hong
Kong Flu” of 1968. A milder epidemic of “Russian Flu” occurred in 1976-78.
The
1918 pandemic killed about 50 million worldwide in a few months. Researchers
have shown that the virus causing the pandemic was, like the H5N1 virus, from an
avian source. A role for bird strains has also been shown in the 1957 and 1968
epidemics, both of which killed a million people in the course of a year.
Since
the latest outbreaks of H5N1 began in mid-2003, the virus has become endemic
(i.e. firmly established) in Southeast Asia, and new cases of AI in birds in
West Asia and Europe suggest the virus is spreading. In addition, studies of the
virus suggest that since it was first detected in humans in 1997, the H5N1 virus
has mutated in ways that might allow it to move more easily from birds to
humans.
Having
said all that, the truth is that the unpredictable behavior of influenza viruses
makes it impossible to predict either the timing or severity of the next
pandemic. This particular strain of virus has been active for 8 years, and 91
deaths in three years out of a world population of 6 billion is a remarkably low
death rate. In any event for a pandemic to occur, the virus would need to
establish effective transmissibility from person to person; something it has yet
to do.
Immunization
and Medications
The
influenza vaccine that is developed each year for seasonal flu does not protect
against the H5N1 virus. Researchers worldwide are working to develop one, but
there is caveat. In order to be effective the vaccine must closely match the
virus that causes the pandemic. That virus will only manifest itself when the
pandemic occurs, and so it will not become commercially available until several
weeks or months after the onset of the global outbreak, and may very well likely
not be available when it is most needed.
Similarly,
there is no known “cure” for AI H5N1. Since it is a viral infection (rather
than bacterial), antibiotics are not effective against it. Antiviral drugs may
decrease the severity of symptoms and possibly shorten the duration of the
illness. Two drugs, oseltamivir (commercially known as Tamiflu) and zanamivir
(commercially known as Relenza), have been shown in laboratory studies to reduce
the severity and duration of illness caused by seasonal influenza and should
work against H5N1 in humans. However the efficacy of these drugs depends on
their administration within 48 hours after symptom onset.
No
Travel Restrictions
To
date, no agency or government has issued any warning against international
travel. However, individuals traveling to affected countries should avoid
settings where they will come into contact with wild birds, poultry farms, or
markets that are selling live animals. For the latest updates regarding Avian
Influenza, go to the WHO website at http://www.who.int/csr/disease/
Avian
Flu and Poultry Products
There
is no epidemiological data that suggest AI can be transmitted to humans through
properly cooked food (even if the food was contaminated with the virus prior to
cooking). There have, on the other hand, been cases of AI infection in humans
that might have consumed dishes containing raw blood.
Basically
this means that you should cook poultry and poultry products evenly and
thoroughly. Similarly, because H5N1 virus can survive at very low temperatures,
you should practice good hygiene when handling refrigerated or frozen meat,
especially in areas where outbreaks of AI have occurred.
The
basic rules you should follow include:
Summary
So
what does this all mean for you and your family? The truth is that at present,
most concerns and media (as well as governmental and scientific) reports have
focused on potentialities, rather than realities.
Only
a small number of people have been infected with AI in the past three years, and
an even tinier number have died. The current H5N1 outbreak is indeed wreaking
havoc and sowing death and destruction in its inexorable movement around the
globe, but the principal victims are birds, which have been dying in the tens of
millions.
If
this virus, or a mutation of it, effectively crosses the species barrier and
then becomes transmissible from person to person, the ensuing pandemic will
likely spread quickly; modern day air travel will guarantee that and the virus
will have spread worldwide before we are even aware it is there.
But
the nature of that pandemic is unknown. While it is almost certain to cause
widespread illness, how severe will it be? It may be a virulent strain with the
ability to slaughter the strong and vigorous similar to what happened in 1918.
Or it may simply behave in the severe, but comparatively mild manner of the
Asian and Hong Kong flu epidemics, killing influenza’s preferred targets: the
very young, the very old, and the weak.
There
will be no effective vaccine in the early days, weeks, and months and the odds
are that the supply of effective anti-virals will be limited, and even when
available restricted to those most at risk.
During
the 20th century, influenza pandemics caused millions of deaths, hundreds of
millions of illnesses, social disruption, and profound economic losses
worldwide. When the next influenza pandemic does strike we can be almost certain
that far more people will be ill and unable to work for a few days than will
likely die. In one conservative scenario it has been calculated that the world
will face up to 100 million outpatient visits, and more than 25 million hospital
admissions. The impact of these absences will snarl the wheels of commerce, cut
down the number of healthcare providers, and take their toll in a dozen little
ways, from sick teachers and empty classrooms, to vacant shops and businesses,
reduced emergency personnel, and so forth.
This
is what a future pandemic can do. So planning for it and understanding how we
will meet it is the best thing we can do and the one thing we must focus our
efforts on.
Read
Also:
**
David Tschanz is an epidemiologist currently based in Saudi Arabia. You
may contact him by sending your emails to: Desertwriter1121@yahoo.com.