By
Kazi Mahmood, IOL South East Asia correspondent
KUALA
LUMPUR, October 8 (IslamOnline) - Software and movie piracy is a well
known phenomenon in Malaysia, but a new form of piracy has taken shape
recently hurting genuine local businesses, an expert on the issue told
IslamOnline on Monday, October 7.
Books
and locally produced Islamic CDs are now targeted by nationwide piracy
syndicates, leaving the victims to seek legal redress or abandon their
copyrighted materials to the pirates.
Several
local companies have complained to the authorities without any action
against the pirates due to lack of evidence and weaknesses in
anti-piracy laws, the experts said.
The
owner of a publication firm based in Kuala Lumpur told IslamOnline that
his best selling books were the targets of piracy by organized groups
determined to violate local copyright laws to make quick money.
“We
had this problem a few years ago when one of our most popular books was
pirated and was being sold outright on the market,” Mohamad A. Ghani
who owns the Darul Numan Publications said.
He
added that it was not easy to go through the process of suing those
responsible for the piracy, as it did not give any result. “End of the
day, we lose money suing these people, and we lose money too with our
books being pirated,”
Another
local firm, based in Bukit Bintang in Kuala Lumpur complained that the
law was not strong enough to punish those found responsible of piracy.
The
company produces multimedia CDs with Islamic contents and is based on
interactive learning. It says it is the victim of piracy too, lambasting
the lack of enforcement to prevent such crimes.
Raids
launched against the printers of pirated books and manufacturers of the
pirated CDs did not hamper the growing business of piracy in Malaysia,
others claim.
Book
publishing is a booming business in the country, with several publishers
making it big in the market. Most of the established book publishers
have several hundred titles on a variety of issues.
The
most pirated books are Islamic books and educational books. The
syndicates print thousands of copies of these books and distribute them
to local vendors under nose of local authorities, Syed Ahmad who writes
for a Tamil newspaper in Kuala Lumpur told IslamOnline.
He
added that he wrote several articles on the issue, sounding the alarm to
the authorities and the local publishers to be more careful and
attentive to the matter.
“It
is believed that people who have huge financial capacity to indulge in
mass production of pirated titles are involved in these syndicates and
that they may be the same people who are in the business of software and
VCD piracy,” Ahmad said.
A
few years ago, Malaysia adopted strict laws to curb piracy and it is
only this year that law enforcement has given some positive results.
Nevertheless, the extent of piracy is so huge that it will take a few
more years and a lot of investigative methods to rid the country of the
venom of piracy, IslamOnline was told.
“When
it comes to software, it is understandable that people cannot afford
original versions at exorbitant prices. For example a copy of Adobe
Photoshop in Malaysia costs U.S.$1500, which is the street retail price.
“A
pirated version of the software that comes with plug-ins and other
associated software costs only U.S.$2 per CD. It is obvious that people
will buy the pirated version unless a solution is found by software
publishers or vendors to make their products more affordable,” Ahmad
said.
He
added it was incredible that the syndicates were now targeting Islamic
books and Islamic CDs that are already cheap and affordable to the
public. He and the producers of the books and CDs are certain that the
aim of the syndicates is to undermine the local businesses.
Ghani
said there seemed no immediate solution to the problem, which was aired
on a local popular TV station a week ago. “If they can show on TV that
piracy is so entrenched in this country, then imagine how difficult it
will be to get rid of this practice,” another book publisher
complained.
The
local authorities, aware of this situation, have launched a massive
anti-piracy campaign in Malaysia. Starting from September 1 this year,
local enforcement officers have the green light to raid suspected
companies and stores for pirated software versions, movies and other
CDs, but books are not in the list.
It
is the duty of the publishers and writers altogether, as well as their
distributors, to approach the authorities so that special attention is
given to book piracy, an enforcement officer working for a division of
the local municipality said.
“All
those concerned should join forces in order to fight piracy at all
levels. We have copyright laws, any one violating these laws are liable
to law suits and fines,” the officer added.