 |
|
Blackwill (L) and Sibal (R) exchange agreements to prevent the extradition of Indian and American nationals
|
NEW
DELHI, December 26 (IslamOnline & News Agencies) – India and the
United States signed a pact Thursday, December 26, under which they
agreed not to send each other's nationals to a world tribunal, in a
victory for Washington's efforts to scuttle the International Criminal
Court (ICC).
The
U.S.-India agreement states there will be "non-extradition of
nationals of either country to any international tribunal without the
other country's express consent," according to Agence
France-Presse (AFP).
It
was signed by Indian Foreign Secretary Kanwal Sibal, the top
bureaucrat in the foreign ministry, and the U.S. ambassador to India,
Robert Blackwill.
"India
and the United States share the strongest possible commitment to
bringing to justice those who commit war crimes, crimes against
humanity and genocide," Blackwill told reporters after the
signing.
"However,
we are concerned about the International Criminal Court (ICC) treaty
with respect to the adequacy of checks and balances, the impact of the
treaty on national sovereignty and the potential for conflict with the
U.N. Charter," he said, quoted by AFP.
Washington
has demanded blanket immunity from the tribunal's jurisdiction for
U.S. peacekeepers, on the grounds that they might be liable to
politically motivated prosecution, the British daily newspaper, The
Independent reported July 2.
"They're
afraid it is going to become a Pandora's Box and that the United
States, which has more than 200,000 troops overseas involved in
peacekeeping and warfighting ... is going to be second-guessed in the
ICC," said Gary Dempsey, an expert at the Cato Institute.
The
daily criticized the inability of the U.S. accepting a minimal risk
which is of no bother to Britain, France and Germany (among 139
countries who have signed the treaty), who play a scarcely less
important role in international peacekeeping operations, and have
welcomed the ICC.
U.S.
President George W. Bush's administration strongly opposes the ICC,
saying the tribunal could bring politically motivated charges against
Americans, including civilian military contractors and former
officials. This fierce opposition to the court shows a certain sense
of vulnerability on the part of Bush administration, said Esther
Brimmer of the Johns Hopkins University Center for Transatlantic
Studies.
The
Indian government has not publicly discussed its agreement with the
United States, announcing it only in a brief foreign ministry
statement, said AFP.
An
official source quoted by the Hindustan Times newspaper said New Delhi
was concerned that a multinational court would "impinge on
national sovereignty."
India
has become angered by attempts to bring its flagrant human rights
abuses in Kashmir to global foray.
The
Rome statute setting up the ICC was signed by U.S. president Bill
Clinton, but he urged his successor not to ratify participation in the
court until Washington resolved its concerns.
India
has neither signed nor ratified the ICC.
Nonetheless,
a total of 139 countries have signed the Rome statute and 87 have
ratified it, according to non-governmental organizations.
The
ICC officially opened in The Hague in July 2002. Eighteen judges are
expected to be elected to the world's first permanent international
court in February 2003.
The
court theoretically has universal jurisdiction, but can only prosecute
if the state where the crimes were committed or the state of the
nationality of the accused are party to the statute.
Faced
with the creation of the ICC, the United States has instead been
trying to reach bilateral agreements under which countries will pledge
not to extradite any U.S. nationals to an international court.
John
Bolton, the U.S. under secretary of state for arms control and
international security, said November 14 that Washington was focusing
its efforts on non-extradition with countries in South Asia and the
Middle East.
But
U.S. officials have been quiet about which specific countries were
being targeted for immunity deals to avoid pressure being placed on
the governments in question.
The
United States have signed such deals with at least 14 other countries,
but India is significant as most of the others are small or closely
identified as U.S. allies.
The
agreement Thursday is a further sign of the warming relations between
the United States and India, which tilted toward the Soviet Union
during the Cold War.
India
immediately joined the U.S.-led "coalition against
terrorism" and in May held their first joint military exercises
in nearly four decades.